Skip to content
News

GTA 6 Has a 99 From Critics and a 5.5 From Metacritic Users: What's Behind the Split

GTA 6's Metacritic user score is 5.5 from about 38,000 ratings, split almost evenly between positive and negative, while critics gave it a 99. What the low ratings say, and how buyers rate it on the PlayStation Store.

By The Leonida Desk2 min read

Lightning strikes over beachfront towers at night under a purple storm sky.
Rockstar Games, via Eurogamer

Critics gave Grand Theft Auto VI a 99 on Metacritic, tying The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the highest score on the site. Metacritic's users give it 5.5 out of 10. By early Saturday, 37,680 user ratings had come in for the PS5 version, and they split almost down the middle: 47% positive, 45% negative and 8% mixed.

Kotaku, Insider Gaming and Notebookcheck call it review bombing: a flood of very low scores, many of them zeros, posted to drag a game's average down. Metacritic opened user reviews shortly after the Nov. 19 release, and unlike the PlayStation Store or Steam, it doesn't ask for proof that you own a game, Notebookcheck notes. Anyone with an email address can rate it.

The score has climbed as more ratings arrive. It was 5.1 from about 10,000 ratings on Friday afternoon, Insider Gaming said, and 5.2 from about 13,000 that evening, according to Notebookcheck.

Where buyers rate it

The PlayStation Store tells a different story. GTA 6 averages 4.84 stars out of 5 there, from about 183,700 ratings on the US store early Saturday. 94% of them are five stars, and 3% are one star.

What the low ratings say

Kotaku read through the negative reviews on Friday and quoted a handful. Some point at real problems: the game runs at 30 frames per second on consoles, PS5 Pro included (our story), and some players have hit bugs. Others object to the game's design: that Jason and Lucia's relationship is at the heart of the story, that you can't hire prostitutes (our story), that there's no PC version yet. Several just call it "woke."

Kotaku's Kenneth Shepard calls the wave part of the anti-woke campaigns that have hit many games over the past decade, while noting that some reviews raise legitimate issues such as the unstable frame rate. Insider Gaming's Ethan Krieger says the comments range from performance problems and lost progress to too much Red Dead Redemption in it and differing political views, and in some cases outright racism. Notebookcheck counts a proliferation of zero scores, some with profanity and nothing about the game itself.

How it compares

Rockstar's earlier games score far higher with Metacritic's users, Notebookcheck notes: San Andreas 9.1, Red Dead Redemption 2 9.0, Red Dead Redemption 8.9, GTA V 8.5 and GTA IV 8.4, though they have had years to collect ratings.

The critic score hasn't moved: it's still 99 (our story). And the game is selling: Take-Two says it sold 32.5 million copies before release and $3.79 billion worth by the end of launch day (our story).

Questions readers ask

What is GTA 6's user score on Metacritic?
5.5 out of 10 for the PS5 version, from 37,680 user ratings early on Nov. 21, 2026: 47% positive, 45% negative and 8% mixed. Critics gave it a 99.
Is GTA 6 being review bombed?
Kotaku, Insider Gaming and Notebookcheck all say so. Thousands of very low scores, many of them zeros, came in once Metacritic opened user reviews after launch, and Metacritic doesn't check that a reviewer owns the game.
Why is GTA 6's user score so low?
The negative reviews mix complaints about the game running at 30fps, bugs and lost progress with objections to its story centering on Jason and Lucia's relationship, to not being able to hire prostitutes, and to the game being "woke," Kotaku and Insider Gaming report.
What do players rate GTA 6 on the PlayStation Store?
4.84 out of 5 from about 183,700 ratings on the US store early on Nov. 21, with 94% of them five stars. Unlike Metacritic, the PlayStation Store asks for proof that you own a game, Notebookcheck notes.

What did you think?

Free newsletter

Get our GTA 6 newsletter

Short, sourced GTA 6 news, guides and tips, by email. Unsubscribe any time.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email.